But the expected miracle did not happen a single time, and every time she lost everything. The girl allie had to choose between her fiance and her first love noah, and the end she chose noah, and she moved in with him. Feb 28, 2019 is netflixs alternative ending to the notebook really so bad. At the end of the notebook, we see allie and noah dead together holding each others hands.
Cut to birds flying over a lake, followed by the credits. Im not bitter any more, because i know that what we had was real. It is about a couple who celebrates 30 years of marriage, and has been described as a sequel to sparks previous novel the notebook. I couldnt sleep last night because i know that its over between us. Allie does remember noah in the end and he does spend the. Think the last five minutes of this years oscars were surprising imagine sitting back, queuing up the notebook on netflix, and being served up a noticeably different ending. Netflix has added the original version of the notebook to its streaming service, after outcry over an alternate ending. The movie focuses on an old man reading a story to an old woman in a nursing home. The ending of the book was only to a point that allie was able to recognize noah despite of her diagnosis to alzheimeris. Yes, the very ending that we all know, love, and have cried. The notebook ending controversially changed by netflix uk film. Netflix apparently changed the ending of the notebook and. Notebook has noah passed away, is he dreaming, or is the ending literal. For the best answers, search on this site whos afraid of virginia woolf.
The 2004 romance movie, which is based on the 1996 novel by nicolas sparks, stars ryan gosling and. The notebook has finally come to netflix, but apparently it has a different ending on the u. It was a great book, and with a cast of compelling characters, it could have been a phenomenal movie but instead, the 2009 film, directed by nick cassavetes the notebook and starring cameron. The notebook apparently has a different ending on u. But the director of the notebook film was very respectful and there are only minor changes and maybe a different interpretation of the ending. Noah from the notebook is actually really toxic but. Others have suggested that this ending is more in line with the book, opening up room to make a movie of the sequel novel, the wedding, which is. The movie ends with the two of them found dead on a bed holding hands with one another. Feb 27, 2019 netflix outrages the notebook fans by streaming version with different ending. The notebook is a 2004 romantic drama film directed by nick cassavetes and written by jeremy leven from jan sardis adaptation of the 1996 novel by nicholas sparks. The notebook is the first novel nicholas sparks published.
I always thought this is what the ending should have been like, so here it is. Do you believe that this kind of love exists in real life. Now, to be quite honest i am not a reader, but for some reason i had a gut feeling that this book would be worth my time, before watching the movie. The happyending version of the film caused a furore this week, and perhaps revealed the future where all films match our psychological preferences. The emotional scale of the movie was increased dramatically that none of the events actually happened in the book. True love exists and theres evidence of it every day. The film the notebook, written by nicholas sparks is a romantic novel that was turned into a film in 2004. The film stars ryan gosling and rachel mcadams as a young couple who fall in love in the 1940s. From the start, noah is obsessed with allie, and dogs. The notebook is a 1996 romantic novel by american novelist nicholas sparks, the novel was. The notebooks ending is different on netflix, and people are. The notebook is by most any objective standard the pinnacle of nicholas sparks adaptations.
Netflix uk uploaded an alternative ending to the notebook. I was able to read it in one sitting as i was drawn into the lives of noah and allie. After being transformed into a movie, there are some critiques who are dismayed by the changes made. The book follows the life of noah and allies daughter, jane and her husband, wilson. Netflix uk accidentally streamed the notebook with an alternate ending. By killing off noah it did not leave any room for the book after the notebook to be produced. The notebook deleted scene getting ready 2004 ryan gosling, rachel mcadams movie hd duration.
Netflix uk accidentally streams the notebook with alternate. This is my ideal ending for the movie the notebook. According to the sun, viewers of the notebook in the past two months have noticed that the ending on their screens was different than the one shown in theaters and on dvd. In the movie version of the notebook, we meet allie and noah during the summer they fall in love. Whenever i read a book i always underline something i find interesting and meaningful. The notebook s ending is different on netflix, and people. Is netflixs alternative ending to the notebook really so.
The last few minutes of the notebook are a tearjerker and a beautiful ending to noah and allies love story. The notebook is an intensely romantic booka novel about the everlasting power of true love. The notebook is a contemporary love story set in the pre and postworld war ii era. Differences between the notebook book vs movie page 3.
It ends differently than the movie does and, in my opinion, has a better ending than the movie. As a stand alone movie the notebook is good movie but having read the book first the movie was a disappointment especially the ending. The story of two young lovers from two different backgrounds. Message in a bottle, a walk to remember, the notebook, nights in rodanthe, dear john, the last song, the lucky one, safe haven, and most recently the longest ride. Have you ever waited for your favorite book to be turned into a movie.
Netflix apparently changed the ending of the notebook. Noah and allie spend a wonderful summer together, but her family and the socioeconomic realities of the time prevent them from being together. The notebook is an achingly tender story about the enduring power of love, a story of miracles that will stay with you forever. In fact, the nicholas sparks bookturnedfilm is so beloved, i wouldnt be surprised if fans could recite it by heart. At the end of the film, noah climbs into allies bed, where they hold hands and talk about miracles. Dec 20, 2012 one difference you do not mention is the ending. So, imagine the internets collective surprise to find out that in the version of the notebook currently playing on u. We want to celebrate our different opinions, and celebrate yours as well. The notebook is an achingly tender story about the enduring power of love, a story of. Netflix outrages the notebook fans by streaming version. The indian bollywood film, zindagi tere naam, starring mithun chakraborty, is also based on it. Feb 27, 2019 netflix uk accidentally streamed the notebook with an alternate ending. Feb 28, 2019 the last few minutes of the notebook are a tearjerker and a beautiful ending to noah and allies love story.
Aug 10, 2011 the notebook deleted scene nobody else for me 2004 ryan gosling, rachel mcadams movie hd duration. Another viewer noted this version is actually true to the book, writing, the alternate ending of the notebook is. The original ends with allie gena rowlandsrachel mcadams becoming lucid after noah james garnerryan gosling reads her the story of their lives. It was the third written after the passing and the. When noah tells his story about his wife slowly becoming ill, you feel how hard it was for him, and for her. Then the scene changes back to the elderly man who just finished reading the story to the elderly woman. They walk together and allie, although she does not. Then when it finally happens you barely recognize it on the big screen. Even though the novel and the movie have different endings, the movie was filled with romance, hard times, and fate. Whenever she remembers the story, she only remembers for 5 minutes, which forces him to read to her constantly.
Too many film sites cater to the same kind of audience, with one overwhelming voice in the writing, but what we treasure at alternate ending is diversity. Noah reads their story from a notebook that was written by allie as a present to noah. And if in some distant place in the future we see each other in our new lives, ill smile at you with joy and remember how we spent the summer beneath the trees, learning from each other and growing in love. Netflix has changed the ending of popular romance film the notebook, causing outrage among fans. Netflix uk is under fire from fans of the notebook for a reported edit to the films final scene that alters the conclusion of the story. Sometimes the title are used to garner the audience of the book especially when the book is a best seller. The notebook ending controversially changed by netflix uk. Feb 27, 2019 netflix uk is under fire from fans of the notebook for a reported edit to the films final scene that alters the conclusion of the story. Fans of the romantic tearjerker he notebook were left outraged upon learning the netflix version playing in the united kingdom omitted the films sad ending for a more happier outcome. Or as one twitter user more succinctly put it, the alternate ending of the notebook is more similar to that of the actual book, and theres a sequel so its def prepping us for the sequel. Set amid the austere beauty of coastal north carolina in 1946, the notebook begins with the story of noah calhoun, a rural southerner returned home from world war ii. At first it is not clear if the two timelines are related through characters or stories, until the reader realizes that the common thread in both spans of time is a notebook. Noah from the notebook is actually really toxic but the.
Netflix has changed the notebooks ending and people are really, really angry mel evans tuesday 26 feb 2019 10. The notebook is arguably one of the most iconic romance movies of all time. Netflix accused of changing the notebook final scene. Their story is read from a notebook in the present day by an elderly man played by james garner, telling the tale to a fellow nursing. Netflix uk uploaded an alternative ending to the notebook cnn. The alternate ending of the notebook is more similar to that of the actual book, and theres a sequel so its def prepping us for the sequel. Feb 27, 2019 think the last five minutes of this years oscars were surprising imagine sitting back, queuing up the notebook on netflix, and being served up a noticeably different ending. According to twitter users, the netflix version fades to black after older allie and noah hold hands in bed. He has seventeen published novels as of september 20 plus one nonfiction. Alternating between memories, of teenage versions of allie and noah the main characters, to older versions of the couple. The movie is wonderful and in the end, i dont know anyone who wouldnt shed a tear. Are there two different versions of the films ending. Last night, my partner and i watched the notebook on uk netflix. In fact, the nicholas sparks bookturnedfilm is so beloved.
In my opinion, the movie is a great addendum to a wellwritten novel. Feb 26, 2019 fans of the romantic tearjerker he notebook were left outraged upon learning the netflix version playing in the united kingdom omitted the films sad ending for a more happier outcome. The notebooks ending has been changed and people are fuming. Their alternate ending is more like the book which has a sequel. Feb 28, 2019 the notebook s ending is different on netflix, and people are freaking out. Were the two endings perhaps the result of differing censorship requirements in different markets, a special directors cut edition featuring previously unused footage, or simply heavyhanded editing by netflix for some reason. In a nursing home, resident duke reads a romance story to an old woman who. One of the famous books is the notebook that was published in the year 1996. I think that noah had been trying for a couple of times to let allie remember everything permanently. He had changed the names in the story to protect her, but he is noah and she is allie. Netflix changed the ending to the notebook and fans are. The notebook by nicholas sparks is a story about two teenagers from opposite sides of the track who meet one fateful summer and fall in love for a lifetime.
But again, i was okay with it as i actually preferred it to the ending of the book, which was a little ambiguous for my taste. Netflix changed the ending of the notebook and people are. Whats the difference between the notebook the book and. He must be for you are the closest thing to an angel that ive ever met. The official website of nicholas sparks, american novelist, screenwriter and producer. It made the most money, for one, which is almost certainly why its the one that is almost always used in the ads for sparks adaptations i. The notebook is about to be added to netflix in the us, but its already available in the uk and fans are not happy with the big change that they made at the end. Imagine sitting back, queuing up the notebook on netflix, and being served up a noticeably different ending. Oct 01, 1996 the notebook is the sappiest, cheesiest, most. Netflix change the notebooks ending and people are angry. The notebook tells the torrid love story of noah ryan gosling and allie rachel mcadams, two people from wildly different backgrounds who fall in love in 1940s america. Netflix uk changes the ending to the notebook indiewire. The story he reads follows two young lovers named allie hamilton and noah calhoun, who meet one evening at a carnival. Is netflix secretly giving us a sequel to the notebook.
The real reason the notebook has a different ending on netflix. The notebook is an eye opening experience of what true love should be between a husband and a wife, for better or worse, or until death does us part read this book, and other nicholas sparks books, he is an amazing story teller. The notebook is a 1996 romantic novel by american novelist nicholas sparks, the novel was later adapted into a popular film of the same name, in 2004. The happyending version of the film caused a furore this week, and perhaps revealed the future where all films match our. I finished the book yesterday and felt strongly compelled to watch the movie again the same day. Is netflixs alternative ending to the notebook really so bad. Netflix adds original version of the notebook after. Apr 07, 2007 this is my ideal ending for the movie the notebook. Nicholas sparks weaves romantic lines from the simplest of words and they turn out cringey and good at the same time.
As it unfolds, their tale miraculously becomes something different, with much. Although noah attempts to keep in contact with allie after they are forced to separate, his letters go unanswered. No dramatically portrayed until death thou us apart scene. Noah and allie spend a wonderful summer together, but her family and the. Whats the difference between the notebook the book and the notebook the movie.
230 30 1011 1500 778 1502 277 1232 214 307 624 96 1291 827 1278 48 864 972 1572 219 1070 1388 677 1390 29 818 349 882 153 1120 1110 1412 567